Singer (Various) - Review
Review by Jack Foley
SINGER is a new compilation album from Sony BMG that takes some of the most well-known singer/songwriter tracks ever produced and brings decades of music together on two CDs.
In doing so, it also attempts to deliver an eclectic mix of acoustic, soul, jazz, blues and pop singer/songwriter classics, whether it’s classics including Wild Is The Wind by David Bowie, Bob Dylan’s Baby, Stop Crying or Simon & Garfunkel’s Bridge Over Troubled Water, to more recent hits such as Amy Winehouse’s Love Is A Losing Game, Newton Faulkner’s haunting cover version of Teardrop, or James Blunt’s 1973.
But is it worthwhile owning? Yes and no. There’s no denying the mix is fairly eclectic, but some of the selections are rather obvious and uninspired. Amy Winehouse, for instance, continues to be given a little too much prominence, while songs from Dido and James Blunt are just plain over-played.
Likewise, the selections from Norah Jones (Come Away With Me), Daniel Powter (Bad Day), Van Morrison (Brown Eyed Girl), and Katie Melua (Nine Million Bicycles). Surely, if you really want to showcase the brilliance of these singer-songwriters, the selections should be a little more surprising rather than conforming to such popular choices. Chances are, you’ll already have these stand-alone tracks among your collection anyway.
More inspired are the selection of Teardrop, from Newton Faulker, or Please Forgive Me, from David Gray, or even Wild Is The Wind, as the Bowie selection. While the likes of Jeff Buckley’s much-celebrated Hallelujah and Dylan’s Baby, Stop Crying are fit to grace any compilation CD.
But, while Singers undoubtedly has some highpoints, it’s a compilation collection that opts to play it safe, rather than really attempting to celebrate the skills of the artists involved.
Track listing:
CD1
Disc 2
- Elton John – Your Song
- Simon & Garfunkel – Bridge Over Troubled Water
- George Michael – Praying For Time
- Annie Lennox – Why
- Kate Bush – Moments of Pleasure
- David Bowie – Wild Is The Wind
- Lou Reed – Perfect Day
- Sade – By Your Side
- KD Lang – Constant Craving
- Bruce Hornsby & The Range – The Way It Is
- Marianne Faithful – The Ballad of Lucy Jordan
- Tori Amos – 1,000 Oceans
- Rickie Lee Jones – Chuck E’s In Love
- Van Morrison – Brown Eyed Girl
- Bob Dylan – Baby, Stop Crying
- Richard Marx – Right Here Waiting
- Stevie Nicks – Has Anyone Ever Written Anything For You
- Sheryl Crow – Run Baby Run
- Carly Simon – That’s The Way I’ve Always Heard It Should Be
